Wednesday, November 18, 2026
HomeNewsNew Documentary Tells Story of Black Teens Who Spent 36 Years in...

New Documentary Tells Story of Black Teens Who Spent 36 Years in Jail For a Crime They Didn’t Commit

Alfred Chestnut, Andrew Stewart, and Ransom Watkins—collectively known as the Harlem Park Three—are three Baltimore men who each spent 36 years in prison for the 1983 murder of 14-year-old DeWitt Duckett. Wrongfully arrested and convicted as teenagers for a crime they didn’t commit, they were finally exonerated in November 2019 following a public records request. Bringing their story to a global audience, the new HBO documentary When a Witness Recants—directed by Dawn Porter and featuring commentary from Baltimore native Ta-Nehisi Coates—premieres today on HBO and streams on HBO Max. To spotlight their fight against the racist criminal justice system, here are five things you need to know about the Harlem Park Three.

A Georgetown University Starter Jacket Was a Key Piece of Evidence in the Case

According to law enforcement, Duckett was killed in a dispute over his blue Georgetown University Starter jacket. In their hunt for the perpetrator, detectives searched Alfred Chestnut’s bedroom and confiscated a similar Georgetown jacket from his closet, treating it as a smoking gun in the case. During the raid, Chestnut’s mother handed the investigators the receipt for the jacket that she purchased weeks before the murder occurred. Also, a Baltimore Police Department (BPD) crime lab test found “zero blood, hair, or fiber transfers from Duckett.” Eventually, officers ignored the receipt and hid the lab findings.

Duckett’s Murderer Was Killed in 2002

Michael Willis, who was just 18 years old at the time of the 1983 shooting, was later identified by Baltimore prosecutors as the person responsible for Duckett’s murder. After the heinous crime was committed, police received several tips that Willis—not Chestnut, Stewart, or Watkins—was the shooter who killed Duckett. Per police records, a witness picked Willis out of a photo lineup as the assailant, and another saw him “run from Harlem Park Junior High after the shooting and throw away a handgun” when law enforcement arrived on the scene. Willis was never charged and was killed in 2002, as The New Yorker reported.

A Public Records Request Helped Alfred Chestnut Break the Case

After years of rejected appeals and denied parole hearings because they wouldn’t confess to a crime they didn’t commit, Alfred Chestnut filed a Maryland Public Information Act request in 2018. He soon discovered that police had withheld the tips about Willis in their reports and that witnesses had testified there was only one shooter. Chestnut sent the documents to the Baltimore State’s Attorney’s Conviction Integrity Unit, which led to a new investigation that ultimately gave the three men their freedom.

Their Combined Sentence Marks a Grim Milestone in U.S. History

By the time of their release on November 25, 2019, Chestnut, Stewart, and Watkins had served 36 years and one day in prison, walking out of their cells at age 52. Having served an unbelievable combined 108 years of wrongful incarceration, their case holds the unjust distinction of being the longest collective wrongful imprisonment in U.S. history

Their Civil Settlement Was the Largest in Baltimore History

After receiving an $8.7 million payout from the State of Maryland in 2020, the Harlem Park Three filed a federal civil rights lawsuit against the Baltimore Police Department. In October 2023, Baltimore’s Board of Estimates approved a $48 million settlement, making it the largest misconduct payout in the city’s history. Adding the state and city payouts, the trio was compensated a total of $56.7 million.

RELATED ARTICLES

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Most Popular

Recent Comments